Real Americans reject fake news. Chain restaurants advertise authentic recipes. Products in automated hypermarkets are touted as organic. Intricately staged and highly edited shows are marketed as reality television.
When a candidate calls for “law & order” in a time of unprecedented peace, the chaos he and his supporters fear is at least partly spiritual. (In addition to being racist.)
The death of God, the complexity of modern institutions, globalization, the plasticity of digital media, the dismantling of colonialism and patriarchy have all contributed to an explosion of doubts.
But the greatest cause of uncertainty for these voters is almost certainly the result of greed. Over the last 40 years, the wealthiest have effectively campaigned to increase the amount of risk and insecurity that others must bear; so that a tiny minority can enjoy more certain returns on their investments, the vast majority must endure greater uncertainty.
This is the terror that drives so many Americans to support Trump. (Expanding social security would probably convert most Trump voters – and maybe even some Trump supporters.)
In this time of uncertainty, the gravest danger we face is to become fundamentalists – not just in our politics but also in our tastes.
It may be that learning to live with doubt is an essential capacity for today.
Rejecting authoritarianism then is not just a political obligation but also a cultural one.
- If you enjoy spirituality, consider reading a book called Fear & Trembling.
- If you enjoy celebrity gossip, considering following the performer Joanne The Scammer.
- If you are invested in your ethnic identity, consider celebrating modern hybrids alongside those who claim to be of pure blood and ancient ancestry.